Itisi

The nebulous ramblings; grammatical & punctuational experiments of a girl born on the fifth of November

Category: socialism

The NHS? It’s what Christ would do

In common with a lot of people in the UK, I’ve been watching the US healthcare debate with mounting bewilderment and indignation, particularly because of the allegations being made about the UK National Health Service (NHS). Over the last week or so, I’ve seen ever more bizarre claims being made about it’s inadequacies, which bear absolutely no resemblance to the system I’ve used all my life. No, it’s not perfect. It’s an enormous organisation run entirely by human beings, and human beings are fallible. However, for the overwhelming majority of people it works. It’s there when we need it; we can visit a doctor, or attend A&E knowing the first question we’ll be asked is ‘what are your symptoms’, not ‘how are you going to pay’.

One of the positive outcomes of all this crazy talk (from people who seem to have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo) is that we Brits have, for once, appreciated just how lucky we are. Yes, we are a nation of whingebags, we like to complain, and complaining about the NHS is right up there with complaining about the weather as one of our favourite national pastimes. However, it’s a bit different when we hear criticism coming from other quarters. That, we don’t like. We might take our health service for granted; we might moan about car parking, cold dinners, rude doctors, but that doesn’t mean anyone else can. As the #welovethenhs threads on twitter show, for the vast majority of people in the UK, the NHS is an important, and fundamental part of our society, one we hold deep admiration and respect for.

At a time when we hear so much about the breakdown of society, it was heartening to see so many people uniting behind a cause that benefits the country as a whole. And surely this unity should send a message to NHS critics across the pond. Shouldn’t they be asking themselves why we hold it in such high esteem if it’s as inadequate and evil as they say? You’d think so, but they won’t, because their response is that we’ve all been brainwashed by a socialist plot. Oh yes, Dear Reader, I am merely a spokeswoman of a Stalinist regime. (This is where I do something I rarely do on this blog, I’m going to swear, in English: To paraphrase Jim Royle – Stalinist plot, my arse!)

It’s easy to see why some people might believe the NHS is socialist; it epitomises Marx’s ideal of  “From each according to his ability, to each according to his need”. But, as anyone with a grasp of British history will know, the NHS (and the labour movement) has it’s roots in good, old-fashioned Christianity. Forget anything Palin the Peabrain and her band of malodorous  minions have told you, the NHS is not an evil, communist brigade who kill people’s grannies, it actually grew out of a long European tradition of religious orders providing healthcare to the poor – which meant pretty much anyone who wasn’t a king or aristocrat. The reason so many British and French hospitals are named after saints, is because they were originally adjunct to monasteries, whose monks tried to emulate the healing work of Christ by providing what passed for medical treatment at the time.

If you are a Christian, you might be familiar with this Christ chappie, and you’ll know that when He wasn’t walking on water or organising large picnics, He healed the sick. At no point during the healing process did He stick out His hand and ask for 30 pieces of silver. That wasn’t His style. He believed He had an ability and it was right for Him to to use it as it was needed. That’s how the NHS works. Collectively we all fund it, assuming we’ll rarely need it, but knowing it will be there when we do. And in the meantime, other people who do need it get the care they deserve as fellow human beings. We do this because we can, and because it’s the right thing to do. I think Christ would approve.

Updated to add: For an amusing video on the topic above, go here. With thanks to Chairman Bill :-)

I appreciate you dropping by,
Please leave a comment, don’t be shy


Internet El Dorado

Today, there is a change from the usual stream of random witterings I offer you in the form of a guest post from Liam, who kindly offered to save you from yet another meme.

Errol Flynn is reported to have once said: “Any man who is not a Communist by the age of 18 is mad, and any man who is still a Communist by the age of 30 is also mad.”

Despite its patriarchal tone (to which I’m sure the owner of this blog will object!) I’ve always been quite fond of this quote. I was an ardent Communist as a young man but by my 30s a gradual loss of faith in human nature led to a growing cynicism towards such utopian ideals. While Flynn’s amusing line might seem to hold some water, more recent developments may well be proving him more wrong than right.

On one level it is easy to agree with Flynn, but has there ever been a Socialist society? Regimes like the USSR and China have much more in common with Fascism than Socialism or perhaps even with Orwell’s 1984. Wherever social revolutions have had a Socialist intention, predatory elements within communities always subverted them to their own power hungry desires. The plot is usually similar to Animal Farm; the pigs end up with their snouts in the trough and the hell with everyone else. Telling Socialists to ‘go back to Russia’ never really made sense; it never was a Socialist regime by any stretch of the imagination.
So am I drawing an incredibly long bow in trying to find any Socialist currents in the online community? Many people have commented on how much people use online communication to share things; free information, images, software etc. etc. with no thought to personal gain at all. These resources are provided by individuals who invest many hours of their time in their distribution with little reward other than sharing as an end in itself. Of course the internet will always be a bastion of capitalism, but is buying and selling necessarily at odds with a Socialist ideal?
People may not be ready to throw away their modern conveniences, march behind a red flag and live on agrarian collectives, but that part never sounded like much fun anyway. As far as egalitarianism and altruism go, the internet may well develop into the new Socialist El Dorado.
(guest post by Liam Alexander)


I appreciate you dropping by,
Please leave a comment, don’t be shy