The NHS? It’s what Christ would do

Wednesday, 19 August 2009, 20:48 | Category : Health, History, News, Politics, Religion, altruism, communism, opinion, socialism
Tags : , , , , , , , , , ,

In common with a lot of people in the UK, I’ve been watching the US healthcare debate with mounting bewilderment and indignation, particularly because of the allegations being made about the UK National Health Service (NHS). Over the last week or so, I’ve seen ever more bizarre claims being made about it’s inadequacies, which bear absolutely no resemblance to the system I’ve used all my life. No, it’s not perfect. It’s an enormous organisation run entirely by human beings, and human beings are fallible. However, for the overwhelming majority of people it works. It’s there when we need it; we can visit a doctor, or attend A&E knowing the first question we’ll be asked is ‘what are your symptoms’, not ‘how are you going to pay’.

One of the positive outcomes of all this crazy talk (from people who seem to have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo) is that we Brits have, for once, appreciated just how lucky we are. Yes, we are a nation of whingebags, we like to complain, and complaining about the NHS is right up there with complaining about the weather as one of our favourite national pastimes. However, it’s a bit different when we hear criticism coming from other quarters. That, we don’t like. We might take our health service for granted; we might moan about car parking, cold dinners, rude doctors, but that doesn’t mean anyone else can. As the #welovethenhs threads on twitter show, for the vast majority of people in the UK, the NHS is an important, and fundamental part of our society, one we hold deep admiration and respect for.

At a time when we hear so much about the breakdown of society, it was heartening to see so many people uniting behind a cause that benefits the country as a whole. And surely this unity should send a message to NHS critics across the pond. Shouldn’t they be asking themselves why we hold it in such high esteem if it’s as inadequate and evil as they say? You’d think so, but they won’t, because their response is that we’ve all been brainwashed by a socialist plot. Oh yes, Dear Reader, I am merely a spokeswoman of a Stalinist regime. (This is where I do something I rarely do on this blog, I’m going to swear, in English: To paraphrase Jim Royle – Stalinist plot, my arse!)

It’s easy to see why some people might believe the NHS is socialist; it epitomises Marx’s ideal of  “From each according to his ability, to each according to his need”. But, as anyone with a grasp of British history will know, the NHS (and the labour movement) has it’s roots in good, old-fashioned Christianity. Forget anything Palin the Peabrain and her band of malodorous  minions have told you, the NHS is not an evil, communist brigade who kill people’s grannies, it actually grew out of a long European tradition of religious orders providing healthcare to the poor – which meant pretty much anyone who wasn’t a king or aristocrat. The reason so many British and French hospitals are named after saints, is because they were originally adjunct to monasteries, whose monks tried to emulate the healing work of Christ by providing what passed for medical treatment at the time.

If you are a Christian, you might be familiar with this Christ chappie, and you’ll know that when He wasn’t walking on water or organising large picnics, He healed the sick. At no point during the healing process did He stick out His hand and ask for 30 pieces of silver. That wasn’t His style. He believed He had an ability and it was right for Him to to use it as it was needed. That’s how the NHS works. Collectively we all fund it, assuming we’ll rarely need it, but knowing it will be there when we do. And in the meantime, other people who do need it get the care they deserve as fellow human beings. We do this because we can, and because it’s the right thing to do. I think Christ would approve.

Updated to add: For an amusing video on the topic above, go here. With thanks to Chairman Bill :-)

I appreciate you dropping by,
Please leave a comment, don’t be shy


  • chairmanbill
    Well said!
  • Glad you agree! I had to write it, I've explained this to NHS detractors who describe themselves as Christian so many times over the last week, I decided it would be easier just to direct them to a post.
  • I'm with you. I'm Australian, and our Medicare system isn't perfect, but I know if I am ever really sick, I can get treated. No worries.

    I don't know what these yanks are going on about - obviously there are lots of them with vested interests.
  • It's absolutely crazy! I can't understand how they hoped to get away with it, do they not realise it's so easy to check that kind of thing nowadays?! Anyhoo, they've had a go at us, and the Canadians, you'll probably be next on the list - they'll be saying your doctors leave old people in the outback or something lol
  • death panels? what planet are our american cousins on
  • I know, it defies logic! How uninformed about the world do you have to be to actually fall for that?!
  • Amen.
  • Thank you Matt :-)
  • Our american cousins are on the planet 'I want to make more money, you can go away and die'. Certainly not a planet that values every human life.
  • The naysayers definitely are! And as I said above, the irony is, the biggest opponents are people who claim to be devoutly religious, I don't see much evidence of that. In fact, if that's religion, I'm glad I'm a heathen.
  • We in the USA currently spend twice as much (over $7,000 per capita) than other industrialized nations on health care, yet over 50 million Americans have little or no coverage. Around 30% of every health care dollar is consumed in a maze of bureaucratic cracks and crevices while, at the other end, physicians/ hospitals inflate their charges and play shell games with health care providers for bigger profits. This has been getting progressively worse for at least 20 to 30 years; it's now reached a breaking point.

    Vested interests certainly exist here, and for too long these profiteers have used catchphrases such as "free enterprise" and "free market" as smoke screens for their own free and selfish goals, stigmatizing anything that stands in their way as "socialistic" or "fascistic"(!). The intensity of the ongoing sound and fury from right-wing groups opposed to President Obama's health care reform is unprecedented. Not only are they criticizing Obama (who they despise to begin with) but are also criticizing countries with national health services (proven to be effective and invaluable) with propagandist smears; in turn, further tarnishing our image in the world and opening us to reciprocal criticism.

    I believe that I'm a real American and not related to such Mammon-like inhabitants of this land referred to as "cousins" with no regard for human life. These do not reflect what the USA (that I know) is all about...if they do, I've been living in the wrong country for the past 55 years.
  • I believe you're a real American too! Fortunately, I've found people like you are a majority, it's just that the minority of selfish idiots are extremely loud! I suppose it doesn't really matter though, they condemn themselves every time they utter yet another ridiculous allegation.

    Really, the whole campaign is an example of how easily uniformed people can be manipulated; anyone with an ounce of common sense would have been dubious about these claims, and checked the facts for themselves. The Stephen Hawking fiasco being a prime example, 30 seconds on Google could have told whoever wrote that article that the man is British.
  • lilystrange
    Nothing I can say that hasn't already been said--only that I'm fully in agreement. The U.S. health care system is certainly not doing the lower and middle classes any good. Maybe some fat cats in the insurance system are profiting but everyone else is struggling.
  • You know my thoughts, we've discussed this elsewhere. You're right, a small number of people are getting very rich, while the vast majority struggle or go without. It's not how it should be and you all deserve much better.
  • chairmanbill
    This Youtube video is quite amusing:

    http://folksopinions.blogspot.com/2009/08/healt...
  • Thanks for that, it's very funny :-) Love the dining room table bit, lmao
  • Oh well said Kate. You've addressed this so well. We may know our NHS but, as you say, whilst we hope not to need it we know that if we do, the treatment of our ailment will be the main priority, regardless of income! It's so reassuring to have it there - quietly doing it's job in the back ground! And, like a protective mother, how dare anyone "outside" criticize it!
  • That's it! It is imperfect, but we are the only ones who are allowed to comment on those imperfections. I was surprised by how much it bothered me to see it not only insulted, but being used to frighten people into rejecting something similar for themselves. Saying that, I don't think it got the naysayers very far, we fought our corner well :-)
  • Kate, what a great avatar! You're worthy of your Yorkshire-ness: all those males you're raising and living with haven't driven you around the bend!

    As an American, I agree with what GrayFoxDown had to say. Unfortunately, after eight years of Bush and his Merry Men, this country is fear-based. Anything as big as an overhaul of the health system scares the road apples out of people.

    Obama has been very unclear, as well as wishy-washy, about how an NHS will work. The health insurance companies, the BIG players in this whole debate, want absolutely no government interference; after all, they make billions of dollars in profits, and I believe they are partly responsible for disseminating disinformation about "total government control" of the system. This scares people, of course, who envision another gigantic and inefficient bureaucracy like social security and Medicare.

    My feeling is, once the dust settles, no NHS plan will be enacted. The lobbyists are the real government—the insurance companies, the American Hospital Assoc., the American Medical Assoc.—and they won't allow a change to the status quo.

    On a lighter note, St. Jude is back blogging as of today.

    Charlie, formerly of Used Kitty Litter
  • Charlie!!! Where have you been? It's lovely to see you commenting here again :-) Just added you on Facebook - aren't you distinguished? And St Jude is back, that's wonderful news! I've missed you both so much. Where do I find her? Is she still in the same place?

    It will be such a shame if you don't get some kind of universal care system! For some, literally a tragedy. But, I can see your point, the lobbyists do seem to have a lot of power - it's the same here, but with different interests.
  • I'm honored to have you as a friend, Kate. Facebook is brand-new to me, so please have patience until I get it all sorted out.

    I'm still blogging, and the URL is on my profile. St. Jude is in the same place, and if you've lost her she is on my blog sidebar.
  • Lol Facebook changes so often it's new to us all, even those who've been there a while. But if you get stuck, give me a yell!

    Found St Jude, and you - added you to the sidebar. I use it as a reading list so I'll be able to keep up with you both.
  • geraldmango
    Kate, the biggest problem in the US is the damn greed. Our government is out of control, our corporations are out of control, there is no balance. Our medical people are some of the most wealthy! They pave their road to success over the graves of their patients. The insurance companies are for profit at any cost. A honest public health care program is so dearly needed! I have lost sight in my right eye, my cost to get it fixed is over 5 grand. Things need to be fixed soon!
  • Oh Gerald, I'm really sorry to hear that :-( Things do need to be fixed soon. You should be able to get your treatment; you've paid tax, brought up a family, contributed to society. It's so very wrong that you have to pay for something so fundamental. I think that's why we are so protective of our system; we know there are vested interests who work to make it like yours - the Tory who appeared on tv in the US to criticise the NHS is a typical example.
  • PS: The hat in your avatar - very cool :-)
  • ladybanana
    I love this post - Just had a very heated discussion with an American Tweeter (who now has blocked me hehehe) about this.

    She is totally convinced by what she reads that our wonderful NHS is somehow useless and evil. Very sad she would not listen to one who has an awful lot of experience in the system both as a user and and as an employee...
  • lol I've noticed that type are very quick to block when they're losing an argument - well done you!

    The ironic thing is, these people accuse us of being brainwashed, yet they're willing to unquestioningly believe the most implausible scenarios simply because someone like Palin tells them it's the truth. Hmm ... what's that called again?
  • Love it.

    Being in Canada we are bombarded with American news and it's quite shocking to be honest. It's like everyone's gone a little mad. The scenerios theyr'e coming up with are way over the top and it's hard to beleive rational people beleive them. And they were attacking our system before they moved on to yours - which is all very frustrating as you say.

    Our systems are all all about everyone being equal and everyone being entitled to the same treatment regardless of their annual earnings. It's universal - as it should be. We all pay for it with our taxes, as you say in your last paragraph - which I completely agree with. And while no system is perfect and will always need to be improved, leaving people to fend for themselves while insurance companies get rich seems cruel to me.
  • I know what you mean when you say it's like everyone's gone a little mad. It's almost as though they're they're competing to see who can come up with the most implausible idea. I've been genuinely surprised to see supposedly intelligent people falling for these stories; I really would have thought common sense would prevail.

    I agree, it does seem cruel. The idea that profit should come before a person's health, or even their life, is horrendous. Just as bad are those who say they have insurance and don't see why they should care about people who don't, that's reprehensible.
  • them_apples
    Very, very well said. Christ would certainly approve of the NHS, there should be no doubt about that. It works it's own little miracles every single day.

    Certain Republicans should be very ashamed of themselves, but then again, they are utterly stupid, so you can't expect much, can you?

    As a lifelong Christian and occasional user of the mighty NHS, I'd never realised why so many hospitals are St. this or that.. Will tuck that one away for the pub quiz...
  • Thanks for the comment :-) Yes, certain Republicans do seem to be monopolising more than their fair share of the world's supply of stupid. I find it bewildering that they can call themselves Christians when they believe something as essential as healthcare should be provided on the basis of ability to pay. I was going to say, do they not see the irony, but the concept of irony is probably wasted on them lol
blog comments powered by Disqus